Jazz Shaped Hip-Hop, but How Did Hip-Hop Change Jazz?
Hip hop’s foundation and evolution owe itself to jazz. And it’s reciprocal. Jazz has borrowed from all facets of hip hop culture and musical contributions, showing that one of the country’s oldest genres is still young at heart. LA Buckner talks to Karriem Riggins about the Dilla formula. Linda Diaz interviews Lakecia Benjamin about the ways hip hop has influenced her as a jazz saxophonist.
(jazzy drum music)
- Jazz and hiphop,
it's a relationship that's ancestral,
two of the most influential music genres
to ever come out of the United States.
The improvisation, grooves, rhythm,
and sound of jazz continues to influence hiphop to this day.
- Hiphop is indebted to jazz.
That's not up for debate.
But let's not act like hiphop hasn't influenced jazz either.
Later, LA and I are gonna work together
to create our own jazz hiphop track,
but first, let's talk about how these genres continue
to crosspollinate today.
- Before we get into the history
of how this crosspollination came to be,
let's test your knowledge on some jazz and hiphop trivia.
Who's the jazz artist
behind this go-to sample
in hiphop? (soft hiphop music)
If you guessed keyboardist Bob James, you're correct.
James has been called hiphop's unlikely godfather,
and has been sampled in over 700 hiphop songs,
making him the most sampled jazz artist of all time.
Next is true or false.
Is Nas's father a trumpet player?
(jazzy hiphop music)
That's true, Olu Dara is a trumpet player
who has played alongside Art Blakey's Jazz Messengers
and, of course, his own son, Nas,
appearing on the rapper's seminal debut album "Illmatic."
Now, one more.
Who's the legendary jazz artist
that has referred to Kendrick Lamar as a genius?
(lively jazz music)
Yep, Herbie Hancock described Kendrick as such
in a 2019 New York Times interview.
So, did you get them all right?
If so, good job.
If not, that's fine, you're gonna learn more now.
- Today, jazz and hiphop are like peanut butter and jelly.
Their relationship is so well known
that it's hard to imagine one without the other,
and despite their musical differences,
they're both an artistic expression
of what it means it be black in America,
but the pairing of jazz and lyrical wordplay existed
long before hiphop was created in the late '70s.
Let's go back to 1920s Harlem,
where black art and literary figures
were leading a renaissance.
There were many figures pivotal
to the Harlem Renaissance,
among them the legendary poet Langston Hughes.
Hughes is credited as the creator of jazz poetry,
which means poetry that demonstrates a jazz-like rhythm
or the feel of improvisation.
Take this live rendition of his classic poem
"The Weary Blues" for example.
- [Langston] The singer stopped playing
and went to bed
while the weary blues echoed through his head.
- [Linda] 40 years after the Harlem Renaissance,
figures like Amiri Baraka would take the idea
of jazz poetry further during the Black Arts Movement
of the '60s and '70s.
- [Amiri] Against his lost white children,
Black Dada Nihilismus.
- By 1970, jazz poetry had found itself
in the hands of people who are now regarded
as hiphop's godfathers,
Gil Scott-Heron and the Last Poets.
A continuation of what Hughes and Baraka did,
Scott-Heron and the Last Poets used cadence,
improvisation, and rhythms of jazz to create poetry
that spoke on the black American experience.
However, where Hughes and Baraka performed
with full jazz ensembles,
Scott-Heron and the Last Poets sometimes performed
alongside just conga players, percussion,
and nothing else.
♪ When the revolution comes ♪
♪ White death with froth the walls ♪
♪ Of museums and churches ♪
♪ Breaking the lie that enslaved our mothers ♪
♪ When the revolution comes ♪
As the 1970s came to a close,
hiphop was born.
The new genre would borrow less from jazz
and more from upbeat disco and funk,
but jazz remained influential,
as you'll soon find out.
- So when did jazz
and hiphop's crosspollination really begin?
Well, you can say it traces back to hiphop's beginnings,
with this 1979 hiphop classic.
♪ You don't stop the rocking ♪
♪ To the bang-bang boogie ♪
♪ Say up junk the boogie ♪
♪ To the rhythm of the boogie, the beat ♪
Yes, that's the Sugarhill Gang's historic "Rapper's Delight"
that begins with a scat rap delivery from Wonder Mike.
Though "Rapper's Delight" made this phrase popular,
old school historians would likely credit its origin
to Keef Cowboy and Lovebug Starski.
This style of rapping is similar to scatting,
a jazz vocal style that uses emotive syllables
instead of words in solo improvisations on a melody.
Scatting was popularized by Louis Armstrong in 1926
when he released his song "Heebie Jeebies."
Although scatting had already existed
before "Heebie Jeebies,"
the song is credited with pioneering the techniques
that became a part of modern scatting.
Fun fact, the scatting
on "Heebie Jeebies" was not intentional.
Armstrong claimed that his sheet music
for "Heebie Jeebies" fell off his stand,
and, not knowing the lyrics,
he instead just made up a melody to fit.
Another hiphop classic to use scatting
is "Planet Rock" by Afrika Bambaata
and the Soul Sonic Force from 1982.
(Pow Wow scats)
Just like Armstrong's "Heebie Jeebies,"
the part wasn't supposed to happen.
According to Tom Silverman,
Soul Sonic Force member Pow Wow had forgotten the lyrics
he had written down going into the fifth verse of the song,
so he improvised instead.
Scatting's influence can be felt
throughout hiphop's evolution.
Think of the fast raps of Kool Moe Dee, Big Daddy Kane,
Busta Rhymes, Twista, and Tech N9ne,
or even the hook from this 2014 hit by Rich Gang.
(Young Thug scats)
There have also been rappers
who have shared how jazz influenced their delivery flow.
Check out the track "Inner City Boundaries"
by Freestyle Fellowship.
♪ I'm me, I'm y'all ♪
♪ The enemy, friend, and the law ♪
♪ The beginner then end-all ♪
♪ The final call, the raw ♪
The phrasing is irregular throughout,
his delivery bouncy and not glued to the tempo of the track,
making for moments when he's slightly ahead of the beat.
Listen to their track "Six Tray"
where P.E.A.C.E. raps over a six-four time signature
in the song's first minute.
♪ Blue-eyed devil killer ♪
♪ Black man, a nine millimeter ♪
♪ In a president's residence, false evidence is evident ♪
♪ Black six tray ♪
♪ Who outta shape ♪
- Now that we've offered some examples
on how jazz influenced rapping styles in hiphop,
let's move on to another example
of the two's crosspollination, improvisation.
Going off the dome and creating in the moment
is built into the fabric of both genres.
Jazz wouldn't be what it is without soloing,
and hiphop wouldn't be what it is without freestyling.
What's the difference between saxophonists Eric Dolphy
and Booker Ervin trading two- and four-bar solos
and rappers Skyzoo and Torae going back and forth?
♪ I never wrote this at the top ♪
♪ You know what we like ♪
♪ Let's do it, baby ♪
♪ You got the Bowery brothers chilling ♪
♪ On Sway in the morning ♪
♪ Listen to it early in the day while you yawning ♪
Now, let's finally address the topic
you're all thinking about, sampling.
Sampling is the bread and butter
of the pair's crosspollination,
and honestly, we could devote a whole episode
to jazz samples in rap
solely from the late '80s and early '90s,
but first, we have to acknowledge
how the breakbeats of hiphop's early days predated the rise
of rap sampling jazz,
because those breakbeats were also taken from jazz cuts.
(lively drum music)
You might remember Bob James
from the quiz at the top.
This is Bob James's "Take Me to the Mardi Gras,"
his 1975 cover of Paul Simon
that became one of hiphop's most recognizable breaks.
In hiphop, the break is all about the drums and percussion.
Hiphop founding figures like DJ Kool Herc
are credited with creating the breakbeat,
which he did by playing two copies of the same record,
and looping its break.
Fellow legend Grandmaster Flash took this further
in his own way, and often used those first 10 seconds
of "Take Me to the Mardi Gras" to showcase his talent.
This break has been sampled by everyone
from Run-D.M.C. to Missy Elliot.
♪ Little Bo Peep cold lost her sheep ♪
♪ And Rip van Winkle fell the hell asleep ♪
♪ Ladies ♪
♪ Woo ♪
♪ You sure know how to work that ♪
In the '90s, hiphop producers took it a step further.
Producers like DJ Premier,
Q-Tip, Pete Rock, and J Dilla,
as well as groups like A Tribe Called Quest
and Digable Planets found melody
and rhythm through looped drum grooves
and saxophone and upright bass parts from jazz tracks.
Now, the MCs were the soloists,
rapping over an array of songs
spanning different eras and sub-genres of jazz.
- I think, like, especially this era
that I came up in music,
listening to records like "De La Soul,"
and "Low End Theory," and "Midnight Marauders,"
a lot of these records introduce a whole new generation
to jazz music.
- Take the track "Jazz (We've Got)"
by A Tribe Called Quest
which sampled jazz organist Jimmy McGriff's recording
of "On Green Dolphin Street."
(soft jazz music)
McGriff's organ and Sam Jones's bass line are looped.
Lucky Thompson's saxophone melody is borrowed
for additional color,
giving it a gritty and moody feel
that complements the punch of the drums
♪ The jazz ♪
♪ The what ♪
♪ The jazz can move that ♪
♪ For the Tribe originates that feeling of pizzazz ♪
- Can you guess which hiphop song samples this song,
"Stretching," by Art Blakey and the Jazz Messengers?
(lively double bass music)
Yet another hiphop classic
that wouldn't be what it is without an upright bass sample.
Here's "Rebirth of Slick" by Digable Planets.
♪ He touch the kinks and sinks into the sound ♪
♪ She frequents the fatter joints called undergrounds ♪
In "Rebirth of Slick,"
"Stretching" literally becomes stretched.
It's fast-paced bebop is much slower
in the rap classic.
Okay, but where are the samples
that use one of jazz's most recognizable instruments,
Fear not, my fellow woodwind enthusiasts,?
Recognize this one?
♪ They reminisce over you ♪
♪ My god ♪
That's Pete Rock and CL Smooth's "They Reminisce Over You,"
which samples saxophonist Tom Scott's cover
of Jefferson Airplane's "Today."
(lively jazz rock music)
- Now, I'm in Pete Rock's band, Soul Brothers.
It's interesting now, because, now,
when you play with him, he's trying to get you
to sound like the out-of-tune sample.
The goal is for the drums
and everything, that broken kinda programmed feel
that they had, the goal is to emulate the things
that weren't real from real people.
- I've got to fit one more sampling example
before we move on,
Nas's classic debut "Illmatic."
Released in 1994,
the album features jazz samples
by drummer Joe Chambers, bassist Stanley Clarke,
the Heath Brothers, and pianist Ahmad Jamal,
the latter of which is the foundation
to one of the album's best songs, "The World is Yours."
♪ Whose world is this ♪
♪ The world is yours, the world is yours ♪
♪ It's mine, it's mine, it's mine ♪
♪ Whose world is this ♪
Right from the jump,
you're hit with a sample from Jamal's "I Love Music,"
taken from the Ahmad Jamal Trio's 1970 album
"The Awakening." (soft jazz music)
- So, even before tuning in,
you knew jazz influenced hiphop,
but what about hiphop's influence on jazz?
Well, throughout the '80s and '90s,
some of jazz's most popular figures
were exploring this crossover.
("Rockit" by Herbie Hancock)
Jazz icon Herbie Hancock dove
into the world of hiphop
with his 1983 hit "Rockit."
This track is important for its use of scratching,
courtesy of Grand Mixer DXT.
The moment validated DJ setups as musical instruments,
and showed its capabilities as a tool for improvisation.
(intense scratch music)
Then there's Miles Davis's "Doo-Bop,"
the trumpeter's posthumous album from 1992.
Davis and Easy had some interesting ideas on here,
most notably on "The Doo-Bop Song."
♪ Just kicking that doo-bop sound ♪
♪ Just kicking that doo-bop sound ♪
The track had that boom-bap drumbeat
that had become a staple in NYC hiphop,
as well has a feature from Easy himself.
♪ Backdrop of doo-hop ♪
♪ And this is why we call it the doo-bop, the doo-bop ♪
In the jazz world, do you feel
like there has been a big influence
from hiphop to jazz?
You know, across three generations,
'80s, '90s, you know, early 2000 kids,
that's, like, your experience.
Your experience is growing up listening to hiphop.
It's not growing up listening to Duke Ellington,
or Cab Calloway, or Charles Mingus.
The first experience you get with music
is hiphop, R&B, and soul,
and, you know, you may get your second experience
when your mom drags you off to church.
- Today's jazz artists are students
of both jazz and hiphop.
And there's one hiphop producer in particular
that left a massive impact, J Dilla.
(soft hiphop music)
- I think just mainly, like, just Dilla,
the way he heard rhythm,
like, syncopation, melody, harmony, chords,
a lot of that stuff was, like, heavily influenced
from, like, Herbie Hancock.
- You know, he embellished on those ideas,
and it just kept elevating him
to use a whole fusion of that stuff
by the time he made it to "Welcome to Detroit,"
it was like another level of just musicology.
- I was listening to Herbie's album
with "Come Running to Me" on it.
- And, like, the little bridge part.
(soft jazz music)
I was just like, oh my god,
this is "Get Dis Money."
- Right, right. (LA laughs)
- For sure.
You probably know of J Dilla's influence in hiphop,
but did you know he influenced modern jazz too?
It all begins with Dilla's approach to beat making,
and the fact that the late producer
didn't quantize every aspect of his beats.
Quantizing allows beat makers
to perfectly subdivide electric drum machine sounds
into positions within a measure.
If things are slightly off beat,
quantizing lines everything up,
but like his jazz ancestors,
Dilla was all about the feel.
Instead of quantizing, Dilla manually did his own drums
on his trusty MPC3000,
and also like jazz, a lot of Dilla's drums were swung.
Notice the difference between drums
that are played straight,
(intense drum music)
and drums that are played swung.
(lively drum music)
(lively hiphop music)
♪ Let me entertain you ♪
♪ And interphase you ♪
♪ With the new sound ♪
♪ Sound is the side ♪
Questlove specifically highlighted this drum pattern
in a Red Bull Talk, referring to the track
as that drunken song
when he first saw the Pharcyde perform it.
- He found his favorite parts of the record
that a lot of people would consider mistakes,
or like a drummer slipping up, or something,
and he'd be like, woo, that's crazy.
Like, but it never happens twice.
- Found those places that he really loved,
and he'd add on a style after that, you know what I mean?
I feel like that's where Dilla came from,
and a lotta that had the swing,
like, you know, a drummer playing,
swinging with the hihat, and the kick late,
and the snare early, that type of thing,
you know what I mean?
- That's the way he heard it,
and he would actually play it on the pads that way.
- Well, I know you're a huge fan,
so I wanted to know,
how was it talking to Karriem Riggins?
Like, what was that experience like for you?
Just, tell me about it.
- He was mad cool.
He was super cool.
- They're always so cool.
- I know, that's the craziest part.
- That's the thing...
They're so cool. - That's the craziest part.
- Seeing, like, okay,
he's a super hiphop dude,
but, like, he's a legendary jazz drummer.
He's like the perfect person,
and PBS always gets, like, the perfect people
to talk to, right? (Linda laughs)
But he was, like, the perfect person
because, when we're talking about hiphop and jazz,
like, that's exactly who he is.
(lively drum music)
One of my mentors tells me,
he was like, oh, no, Dilla, like, gave Karriem the formula.
Like, he was there next to Dilla
when he was doing a lot of that stuff.
- That's so awesome.
- Dilla's style has not only inspired other beat makers,
but jazz musicians too.
On his 2007 album "In My Element,"
Glasper included a tribute to Dilla titled "J Dillalude,"
which found him reinterpreting melodies
that Dilla looped in his production.
(jazzy hiphop music)
Through Dilla, Glasper found ways
to bring hiphop and jazz together,
both on recordings and live performances,
but he took that even further
with his Black Radio series,
which pairs jazz musicians like himself,
Chris Dave, Casey Benjamin, and others
with rappers ranging from Lupe Fiasco
and Yasiin Bey to Common and Snoop Dog.
♪ Vicariously in every rap I speak with ♪
♪ I hope you speak it for me ♪
♪ If I'm ever speechless ♪
- Now, this brings us to the present,
where the line that once separated jazz
and hiphop has become very blurred.
We're in a post-genre era,
and many artists don't wanna be put in a box.
- I'm so not into now the label of these genres blending
because it's so, like,
I listened to hiphop growing up,
I listened to jazz, and classical,
and all these things that I love.
I feel like it is one thing.
Like, what you listen to is just like a soup,
and you can't really define one thing in a soup,
but it all makes incredible.
♪ Pat Dawg, Pat Dawg, Pat Dawg, my dog, that's all ♪
♪ Bick back and Chad, I trap the bag for y'all ♪
- Kendrick Lamar's groundbreaking "To Pimp a Butterfly"
is a testament to how far that crosspollination has come.
"To Pimp a Butterfly" was a melting pot of black music,
and he used jazz in such a creative
and meticulous way thanks to musicians
like Glasper, Kamasi Washington,
Thundercat, and Terrace Martin.
♪ Pipe pressure, bust 'em twice ♪
♪ Choice is devastated, decapitated the horseman ♪
♪ Oh, America, you bad ***** ♪
♪ I picked cotton and made you rich ♪
The album does more than just bring jazz musicians
and rappers together.
It explores the musical nuances and sonic subtleties
between the two genres.
- But "To Pimp a Butterfly" is but one example
of how varied this crosspollination is today.
Noname, Flying Lotus, Kamasi Washington,
Thundercat, Louis Cole, Shabazz Palaces,
Hiatus Kaiyote, Moonchild,
Standing on the Corner, Masego,
Nubya Garcia, Melanie Charles,
BadBadNotGood, Nujabes, so many artists
and groups across the world
are defining and redefining that relationship.
Even internet sub-genres like lo-fi hiphop
play a part in this.
Lo-fi hiphop livestreams on YouTube
utilize jazz's distinct chord progressions
and the drunken swing of Dilla.
- The crosspollination of jazz and hiphop
isn't just a fad, but it's something
that continues to have an impact.
It's constantly evolving, and it's moving to its own beat.
Now, let's check out the jazz and hiphop-inspired track
that Linda and I have been working on.
- It's interesting
because I was expecting something that was...
Like, okay, so, when I think of hiphop and jazz,
the people around me, it's very, like, jazz hop,
and that's not what you did,
not in a bad way.
Like, I feel like the way you did it was so creative,
and, like, unique to you.
- I was really struggling, you know,
but I think, like, the pressure of,
like, okay, Karriem is gonna hear this,
Robert Glasper might hear this,
Terrace might hear this, like,
so it has to be good,
but then I just settled with the idea,
like, well, if I like it, if I dig it.
- You know, if I like what happens,
like, it'll be fine.
♪ La la la la ♪
♪ La la la ♪
♪ La la ♪
♪ Ah ♪
All my keys be like this, played like this.
I don't play, like, full fingers, full hands.
All my joints be, like (grunts)
- Yeah (laughs)
- Layer, layer. - Same.
- I call that cheating.
People be like, no, that's producing.
That's how you get it done.
- It is.
♪ Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah ♪
- I was up at, like, 4:00 in the morning
thinking about, like, okay,
what am I gonna do for this song?
- [Linda] Mm-hm.
- I just did a groove that I dig
kinda in between swung and straight.
If you listening, you can't really tell
if it's swung all the way or straight all the way.
I like that cloudiness.
- I ended up, like, writing in the spaces in between
as opposed to, like, on top of the melodies that existed,
intentionally, for rhythm's sake.
I think, you know, I could've added,
like, six different harmonies,
and that would've been very jazz, I think.
- Right, super.
- [Linda] Yeah, but I was like,
I'm gonna just have this one harmony.
More Episodes (37)
The Genius of Fela Kuti and AfrobeatMarch 01, 2021
Jazz Shaped Hip-Hop, but How Did Hip-Hop Change Jazz?February 01, 2021
Why Puerto Rican Bomba Music Is ResistanceJanuary 07, 2021
Why Is Jersey Club Music Everywhere?January 06, 2021
Noise and Experimental Music Is for EveryoneOctober 21, 2020
How Charlie Parker Changed Jazz ForeverAugust 28, 2020