HUD's Ben Carson on public housing and political 'spin'
The Department of Housing and Urban Development assists more than five million families with affording their rent, among other programs. Yamiche Alcindor talks to HUD Secretary Ben Carson about his reaction to President Trump's rhetoric on race, whether Carson plans to remain in his position, HUD achievements during his tenure and criticism he's received about his use of government resources.
AMNA NAWAZ: President Trump's proposed budget would cut funding for the Department of Housing
and Urban Development by 18 percent, including cuts to public housing programs.
Yamiche Alcindor takes a closer look now at some of the challenges the department is facing
and solutions its leadership is considering.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: Through federal rental programs, HUD assists more than five million families
to have a home.
For the past two years, decisions about how to spend the department's $50 billion budget
have been made by Dr. Ben Carson.
Secretary Carson joins me now.
Thank you so much for being on the program tonight.
I first want to talk to you about President Trump.
He recently suggested that white supremacist groups are -- quote -- "a small group of people."
Experts in organizations that study white supremacists say that they're actually a growing
group and that they're leading to a rise in hate crimes across the country.
Do you agree with the president's stance on white supremacists?
BEN CARSON, Secretary of Housing and Urban Development: Well, I don't know that anything
useful comes from talking about what size they are.
They're a despicable group of individuals, as any group that hates others and purports
themselves to be superior.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: But the president said that they're still a small group.
Do you see them as a rising issue?
Should the government be dealing with them in some way?
BEN CARSON: Well, I think we should all, regardless of what our political prospects are, condemn
anybody who is a hate group, no matter what their size, whether they're getting smaller,
whether they're getting larger.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: But the problem is getting worse, you think, or...
BEN CARSON: I personally have not seen evidence of it.
But, again, if there is even one, it's a problem.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: And you said recently that you're open to serving a second term as HUD
secretary, but you also said that you might leave after first term.
Are you concerned -- as the only black Cabinet member for President Trump, are you concerned
that the lack of diversity in the Cabinet and in the administration might impact the
president's rhetoric and policies?
BEN CARSON: Well, first of all, I indicated that, you know, I would prefer to be in the
I would prefer to be in the private sector now.
This is sacrificial work.
However, it's very important work, because, for an extremely long period of time, you
know, the poor people in our country have been taken for granted.
And, you know, we have concentrated, both administrations, Democrats and Republicans,
on getting people under roof and getting them into programs.
We haven't concentrated on, how do you get them out of those programs in an economically
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: Are you worried about the lack of diversity, though, that the administration
would have if you left?
BEN CARSON: I am not concerned about what happens if I leave.
But I do believe that there needs to be a representative sampling of our society.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: You have said that poverty is a state of mind.
Do you still believe that?
BEN CARSON: Again, let me correct the record.
What I said is, largely, a part of the mind-set, because -- I give it as an example, if a rookie
playing baseball comes up and, you know, his first time at bat and there's Nolan Ryan out
there, he says, Nolan Ryan, oh, no, he's got a 95-mile-an-hour fastball.
I'm probably not even going to see it.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: But you have said that it's still largely a state of mind.
BEN CARSON: Well, let me finish.
And then another rookie comes up and says, Nolan Ryan?
He's an old man.
I'm going to knock the cover off this ball.
A lot depends on how you look at it.
That doesn't mean that you don't sympathize with people who are poor and that you don't
understand why they're in that situation.
Many people grow up in a situation where they don't have an opportunity to see any other
way of life.
So, naturally, they feel that way.
You couple that with some of the things that are in the way -- for instance, if you're
getting assisted housing, you're told that, if you make any more money, you have to report
that, so your rent can go up.
If you bring another person into the household who is making money, you have to report that,
so your rent can go up.
Don't even think about getting married.
Not only your will rent go up.
You may lose your subsidy altogether.
These are not useful things.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: Well, you're talking about rent going up.
You have called for tripling the rents on people living in public housing.
What do you say to people who think you're making life harder for poor people?
BEN CARSON: Well, I'm glad you brought that up, because what we're talking about are the
people who pay the minimum rent of $25 to $50 who are able-bodied.
We're not talking about disabled people.
We're not talking about elderly people.
We're talking about people who are perfectly capable of working, who are paying $25 to
$50 a month.
We need to get those people stimulated.
They need to get out there.
This is a perfect time.
There's actually more jobs out there than there are people to do them.
And, you know, we need not to couch and coddle these people, but we need to develop them.
It'll be for their own good.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: And you have said that you came to HUD to fix the rats, the roaches,
the lead, the violence.
But HUD records show that, last year, more families lived in HUD housing that failed
health and space -- and safety inspections than before, as compared to 2016.
It was a rise of 30 percent.
What do you say to people who think, under your leadership, under your tenure, public
housing has become more dangerous to live in?
BEN CARSON: I think they should find out what the real facts are.
The real facts, I have been very concerned about this.
So we have stepped up the inspection process,and we put more controls on it.
So, obviously, you're finding things that were glossed over before.
That's going to be the case.
And we're doing something about it.
We decreased the number of days to 14 for an inspection, so you don't have time to cover
over all the things.
And we're training the inspectors the right way.
We're bringing I.T. systems in, so that we get consistency.
These are things that take time.
And you can spend them any way you want, depending on what your political perspective is.
But we're concerned about the people.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: Your administration has championed opportunity zones, and your signature
program is EnVision Centers.
But some of these centers and some of these opportunity zones, experts say, have failed
to garner financial backing from the White House and from the private sector.
Can you point to one tangible achievement that EnVision Centers have achieved since
you have been at HUD?
BEN CARSON: I'm glad you asked that question, actually.
You know, in Chicago, the EnVision Center there is having a system where they take addicts
and they give them medically assisted treatment, programs that will actually get them out of
In Detroit, they're actually teaching young people some skills, like how to run a pizza
You know, what people don't recognize is that, when you create a new program, you don't just
declare it and it pops up.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: Just to be sure, those are all open EnVision Centers?
Because I was reading some -- that there was a soft opening in Washington state.
Are the other ones that you're talking about open already?
BEN CARSON: Yes, they're already functioning.
And there are more, several more, that are going to be opening before the summer is over.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: And I want to ask you about the group, the watchdog group American Oversight.
They got ahold of some of your schedules.
They said that you went to Florida dozens of time -- dozens of time.
They also say that you and your wife...
BEN CARSON: Actually, they said I went a dozen times.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: They said that you went several times or a dozen times.
They also had e-mails that showed that you and your wife were directly involved in purchasing
a $31,000 dining room set for your office.
What do you say to people who think that that schedule and...
BEN CARSON: I'm glad you brought that up.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: ... and that also -- and that dining set, that they are really not
aligning with the mission of HUD?
BEN CARSON: I'm glad you brought that up, because, as you know, in Washington, D.C.,
most of the members of Congress go home frequently on the weekend.
It wouldn't be any different for a Cabinet member, quite frankly, and many of them go
home on Thursdays.
They're complaining about the fact that I left on Friday afternoon.
If that's all they have got to complain about, I think we're in pretty good shape.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: What about the dining room set and how that aligns with HUD's mission?
BEN CARSON: I find that kind of hilarious, because you would have to look long and hard
to find anybody who cares less about furniture than I do.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: But you were directly involved, along with your wife?
BEN CARSON: And even harder to find somebody who's more thrifty than my wife.
We were involved only in the sense that they said, you need to look at these catalogs and
tell us what you want to pick, because this has to be done.
They said, the furniture that's in there is no longer repairable.
We have tried to repair.
It's there for 50 years.
And then they try to say it's a table that cost $31,000.
It was 17 pieces of furniture.
And anybody who knows anything about solid furniture knows that that's not an exorbitant
And that was the government catalog that they ask you to choose from.
So what was really going on is, there were people who wanted to say, you're cutting the
budget on poor people, and you're buying expensive furniture.
That's the only narrative they wanted.
They didn't want the truth.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: And those people would be wrong?
BEN CARSON: They would be extraordinarily wrong.
And it would be wonderful if people would actually look for the real news and not try
to create these narratives.
YAMICHE ALCINDOR: Well, thank you, Secretary Carson.
I really appreciate you coming on tonight.
BEN CARSON: Absolutely.
More Episodes (307)
April 21, 2021 - PBS NewsHour full episodeApril 21, 2021
April 20, 2021 - PBS NewsHour full episodeApril 20, 2021
April 19, 2021 - PBS NewsHour full episodeApril 19, 2021
April 18, 2021 - PBS NewsHour Weekend full episodeApril 18, 2021
April 16, 2021 - PBS NewsHour full episodeApril 16, 2021
Beyond the Canvas | Season 2 | Episode 3April 16, 2021